The Political Strategies of Impeachment – “Sunday Political Brunch” - December 15, 2019
Sunday, December 15, 2019
“The Democrat’s Dilemma” – The current breakdown of the 435-member House is 233 Democrats, 197 Republicans, 1 Independent, and 4 vacant seats. You need a simple majority of 218 votes to pass an article of impeachment. Now Democrats came to power in 2018 by winning about 30 seats in toss-up districts that Donald Trump carried in 2016. The leadership will likely “allow” up to 15 Democrats to vote “no” on impeachment, so that they can save their own seats, and preserve the overall Democratic majority in the House. The House may indeed pass articles of impeachment by the slimmest of majorities.
“Republican Redux?” – If the above scenario sounds a bit cynical, well it is. But are Democrats doing something new? Hardly! Republicans have done similar. Back in 1996, two years after Republicans seized the House of Representatives for the first time in 40 years, the GOP faced a dilemma. With President Clinton steaming towards a second term, there were concerns his coattails might pull Democrats back in charge of the House. In order to preserve his majority, House Speaker Newt Gingrich told a handful of moderate-to-liberal House Republicans to run against him if they needed. In fact, they could trash Gingrich – and some did – if that would help them get reelected. Crazy you say? No, Gingrich needed their votes on big deal items like the budget. And he needed them to win to stay in power. It worked as the GOP held the House.
“Gee, Oh? People Concerns” – While it seems a foregone conclusion that Democrats will impeach President Trump, there don’t appear to be the 67 votes in the Senate to remove him from office. But that doesn’t remove the political pressure. Republicans hold a thin 53 to 47 majority in the U.S. Senate. But Republicans are at a strategic disadvantage. They will defend 23 seats in 2020, while Democrats will defend just 12. That imbalance bodes well for the minority party which only needs a net gain of 3 or 4 seats to retake control of the Senate.
“Trump v. McConnell” – How the impeachment trial will go in the Senate is the subject of much speculation. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell would very much like to call the Senate into session and immediately make a motion to acquit, which would likely pass. But President Trump is wanting a lengthy trial in which he can call witness to testify, including former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter. Not only does Trump want vindication, he wants the political leverage of securing his own base, and perhaps reaching a good number of independents who view the impeachment process as a colossal waste of time and money.
“Be Careful What You Wish For!” – First of all, a quick trial and acquittal from McConnell’s Senate Republicans could backfire if the public feels like “the fix was in.” And remember, McConnell is one of those 23 Republicans up for re-election in 2020. Plus, if it looks like he coordinated his quick “song and dance” with the While House, Democrats will cry jury tampering, since the Senate is acting as the jury! If they go with Trump’s lengthy trial strategy, there could be pluses and minuses. Obviously, a long trial, say from January through April, could freeze the Democratic presidential candidates who are also Senators, and that helps Trump. But if Trump appears so focused on his lengthy trail, what else will get done in Washington? Likely nothing – as we learned from Bill Clinton’s impeachment - and that potentially hurts Trump.
“The Side Show” – The problem for all sides in this is that there is other business to attend to. Yes, on the very day the House Judiciary Committee passed two articles of impeachment against Trump, the China-U.S. trade war was seemingly fixed. That looks like Trump is busy working and getting stuff done. On the other hand, the U.S.-Canada-Mexico trade deal still needs to get fixed, and then there’s that pesky continuing resolution to keep the government funded and open beyond the Friday deadline. If Trump and the Senate can’t get this done, they’ll be labeled the “Do Nothing Republicans” by Democrats.
“The Parallels of History” – As I wrote abut a few weeks ago, Trump’s impeachment is more like President Andrew Johnson’s, and less like Presidents Nixon and Clinton whose impeachment inquiries began after they were elected to a second terms. Trump and Johnson were facing impeachment within their reelection year. Johnson’s trial dragged into May, and he was so wounded (though not removed from office), that he lost his renomination effort just two months later in July. Perhaps this is another reason why Trump needs a shorter - not longer - trial, if he is to survive politically.
To impeach, or not impeach? Please weigh in with your position and reason, by clicking the comment button.
Related Articles
- White House Politics: Chaos, Crisis, or Calm? – Sunday Political Brunch - December 16, 2018
- Where’s the “Blue Wave?” – Sunday Political Brunch May 27, 2018
- Who Do Democrats Want for Vice President? - “Sunday Political Brunch” - September 15, 2019
- Why Trump Won the White House - Sunday Political Brunch May 26, 2019
- Will May’s Primary Political Colors be Red or Blue?—Sunday Political Brunch May 6
- Where Presidential Candidates Stand on Guns - “Sunday Political Brunch” - August 18, 2019
- When the White House Becomes a Prison—Sunday Political Brunch January 13, 2019
- What Matters at the Election Finish Line—Sunday Political Brunch - November 4, 2018
- What the 2018 Elections Tell Us About Campaign 2020—Sunday Political Brunch June 9, 2019
- What’s Next After Fallout from Debate Round #3? - “Sunday Political Brunch” - September 22, 2019
- “A Summer of Political Drama Heads to Fall” - Sunday Political Brunch - September 9, 2018
- “Come See About Me” - The Supreme Court Picks—Sunday Political Brunch July 8, 2018
- “The Sunday Political Brunch” - February 21, 2016
- “The Sunday Political Brunch” - February 14, 2016
- “The Sunday Political Brunch” - February 7, 2016
- “The Sunday Political Brunch” - January 31, 2016
- “The Sunday Political Brunch” - September 11, 2016
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It