Bruun’s Views: NLRB Ruling Bad for Oregon Business
Wednesday, December 16, 2015
These Oregon small businesses may now need to add the NLRB to the list of worries. A recent ruling by that board, if implemented, would turn longstanding employee and employer relations on its head.
The challenge arises from a NLRB ruling in the case of “Browning-Ferris.” In the case (decided in late August) the NLRB redefines what it means to be a “joint employer.” According to the NLRB, rather than exercising direct control over employment, businesses must have only the mere “right” to exercise control now to be considered a joint employer. This change casts a shadow of uncertainty over just about any business-to-business relationship.
Any business that engages in user-supplier, lessor-lessee, parent-subsidiary, contractor-subcontractor, franchisor-franchisee, predecessor-successor, creditor-debtor, and contractor-consumer relationships could be pulled in. In other words, every Oregon small business that engages in contractual relationships.
It’s worth noting that the actual board of the NLRB consists of 5 members appointed by the President. As such, the composition of the board largely reflects President Obama’s philosophies and political agenda. This means that the current NLRB board marches in lockstep with the whims and desires of Big Labor.
The NLRB’s Browning-Ferris decision unwinds decades of precedence. No doubt, it was done to help expand collective bargaining powers and opportunities for Big Labor. Namely, to pull small mom & pop franchisees businesses into larger labor and workplace negotiations.
This will be incredibly bad for those small businesses, whether restaurants, hotels, hardware stores, gyms or any other franchised small business. It will be equally bad for any other small business that relies on contractual relations to perform. Like Oregon’s construction contractors.
Construction in Oregon, from small homebuilders and remodelers to commercial contractors and subcontractors, will be thrown into an environment of legal limbo, uncertainty, employee-employer tension, and increased operating costs under the NLRB’s broadened definition.
Success in construction contracting, as for other industries, includes building and developing strong relationships across a variety of specialty trades and synergistic vendors. Builders establish and manage contractual relationships with a broad array of design and trade professionals. Think of, for example, the contractor who manages the independent plumber, painter and electrician who all work to accomplish a kitchen remodel. The NLRB decision will now force all of these independent small businesses to reexamine every existing relationship.
Oregon’s contractors employ thousands of Oregonians. Construction was the hardest hit industry during the Great Recession. While improved, the industry has not fully recovered. The last thing Oregon’s beleaguered construction workers need now is an ill-considered and disruptive mandate out of Washington D.C.
But that’s now what they’ve got.
Without a fix, Oregon’s contractors will have to take on a new level of risk since they may soon be liable for the employment practices of other firms they do business with. To avoid this, those same contractors may choose to limit contractual risks by expanding their own operations. Yet expanding beyond core expertise or financial wherewithal creates other risks. Trying to self-perform heretofore contracted services would be a dangerous venture for many Oregon contractors.
Thankfully, there is a much better solution: Repeal the NLRB’s decision.
Legislation in congress, the Protecting Local Business Opportunity Act, would do just that. The bipartisan bill, chief-sponsored by Tennessee senator Lamar Alexander of red plaid-shirt fame, would restore the original and long-standing joint employer standard.
Nationally, one of the most influential senators on this issue is Oregon’s own Ron Wyden. Wyden’s past support of common-sense business policies -- like international trade agreements and working timber initiatives -- means that his voice on the joint employer issue will go a long way.
Ron Wyden, along with the rest of Oregon’s congressional delegation, needs to understand how important this issue will become for Oregon’s small businesses and construction industry. Our working families -- those construction families -- have suffered much over the last eight years. While conditions have improved somewhat, wages remain stagnant and consistent job growth opportunities are still too rare.
Oregon’s leaders can do much to help the situation. Fostering the right public education policies, the right tax policies and the right trade policies will help. So will getting federal regulatory policies right. In fact it’s critical.
A positive step on that regulatory front starts by saying ‘no’ to the NLRB’s needlessly disruptive joint employer ruling.
Related Slideshow: Slideshow: Oregon Receives Average Ranking for Business Climate
The state of Oregon is neither the best nor worst state to run a company, according to data pulled from nationwide business publications and testimonies from Oregon business owners.
Related Articles
- Scott Bruun: The Challenges Legislative Democrats Face in 2015
- Scott Bruun: The Beaver State’s Lame Duck
- Scott Bruun: The Future As Seen In Seaside
- Scott Bruun: The Importance of Winston Churchill in Portland
- Scott Bruun: The Problem With Congress’s Work Schedule
- Scott Bruun: The Next Jack Kemp
- Scott Bruun: Ted Wheeler’s Wheel of Big Government Solutions
- Scott Bruun: State Senator Betsy Johnson’s Possible Run for Governor
- Scott Bruun: Recalling Forward – Peace, Joy and Goodwill
- Scott Bruun: Presidential Politics in Oregon
- Scott Bruun: Recalling the Recall of Three State Legislators
- Scott Bruun: Ronald Reagan in Portland and the Burbs
- Scott Bruun: September 11th – Fourteen Years On
- Scott Bruun: Salem and Olympia – A Tale of Two Cities
- Scott Bruun: The Problems With Portland’s City Government
- Scott Bruun: The Rise of Greg Walden
- Scott Bruun: Why Oregon Needs Allen Alley in the Governor’s Office
- Scott Bruun: Why I’m Thankful For Former Portland Attorney, Kelly Clark
- Scott Bruun: Why the GOP Should Look to Portland’s Urban Conservatives
- Scott Bruun: Why The Oregon Zoo is Awesome
- Scott Bruun: Wyden and the Politics of a Bad Iran Deal
- Scott Bruun: Working Oregonians Hurt By State Policies
- Scott Bruun: Why Choosing Lynne Saxton Is A Smart Move for Kitzhaber
- Scott Bruun: Two for Oregon’s Future
- Scott Bruun: Time for a Spring Cleaning in Salem
- Scott Bruun: There’s No More Political Giants in Oregon
- Scott Bruun: Time to Manage Those Californians
- Scott Bruun: To Boldly Go Where No Ad Has Gone Before
- Scott Bruun: Trees, Fees and Re-election Please
- Scott Bruun: Portland’s Uber-Control Over Free Markets
- Scott Bruun: Portlandia’s Radical Marionettes
- Scott Bruun: Dorchester Conference - Oregon’s Unique Brand of Activism
- Scott Bruun: Does Portland Really Want Your Business?
- Scott Bruun: Education, Priorities, and the Governor’s Budget
- Scott Bruun: Federal Budget Politics Put Oregon Fishermen At Risk
- Scott Bruun: Gun Laws, Politics, and Hearts of Darkness
- Scott Bruun: Give Us Our Kicker, For Now
- Scott Bruun: Death and Taxes in Oregon
- Scott Bruun: Could Marco Rubio Win Oregon?
- Scott Bruun: A School Week and Its Discontents
- Scott Bruun: A Happy Old Horse Versus Oregon Law
- Scott Bruun: A Vote for Abigail Scott Duniway on #TheNew10
- Scott Bruun: An Early Look at Portland’s Mayoral Race
- Scott Bruun: Conversations about Portland’s Future
- Scott Bruun: Climbing with Kate
- Scott Bruun: Hate Crimes and the Big Red O
- Scott Bruun: How Ron Wyden Can Lead The U.S. Senate
- Scott Bruun: Oregon’s Failing Grade in Ethics
- Scott Bruun: Oregon’s Race for Secretary of State More Important Than Ever
- Scott Bruun: Oregon’s Path Away From One Party Rule
- Scott Bruun: Oregon’s Public Pension Catastrophe
- Scott Bruun: Passing Marks for Political Courage in Support of Free Trade
- Scott Bruun: Our Kitzhaber Conundrum
- Scott Bruun: Oregon’s Cougar Problem
- Scott Bruun: Oregon Should Say No to Open Primary
- Scott Bruun: Kitzhaber - A Smoking Gun Four Decades in the Making
- Scott Bruun: Jim Westwood’s Declaration of Independence
- Scott Bruun: Like A Ship In the Night
- Scott Bruun: Oregon Needs a Pacific Rim Trade Pact
- Scott Bruun: Oregon Should Not Limit Campaign Contributions
- Bruun’s Views: Vic Gilliam, We Salute You
Follow us on Pinterest Google + Facebook Twitter See It Read It